"He shall from time to time give to the Congress Information on the State of the Union,..." - and thus the mandated report begins again for this year. It being an annual event is mostly due to tradition, and the oral address is a relatively recent return, as writing was the popular form for much of the United States' existence. This particular address follows an inaugural address talking about the history and shared struggles of the nation and its peoples as well as a mass shooting that appears to have galvanzied public opinion. Perhaps because those killed were defenseless children and their teachers. Perhaps not. In any case, I'm using the remarks as delivered by the President in the actual speech.
The beginning is normally boilerplate, or sometimes a stretch, to show off the things that are improved in the union this past year. Considering we're still crawling ourselves out of a recession, there was a lot of low-hanging fruit to pick. Recognizing that there was still a long way to go helped. Making mention that the remining war and its cost can come to an end soon is also a good thing. Pointing out that the American people expect their government to govern could have been a much sharper edge used, if one were trying to go for accuracy, but just saying so probably caused gasps in the mainstream media.
Then come the commonsense reforms - cut defense, reform the tax code to be fairer, and STOP BEING OBSTRUCTIONISTS, GOP. Increase jobs by funding projects to innovate in many areas.
Plank two: climate change. Start shooting for multiple targets - energy independence, reduced climate emissions, and more/better renewables and clean energy. Fix the infrastructure that supports all of these innovations. (It creates jobs!) Let people refinance their mortgages so as to free up some money.
Plank three: Universal preschool and high schools that can get students out with the skills needed to get jobs. Early learning research says that having quality preschool is very helpful for getting kids ready for schooling. And if our high schools could graduate students that could get good jobs, that's excellent, instead of requiring a collegiate degree to make minimum wage in an unrelated field.
Plank Four: Raise the standard of living. Reform immigration, DREAM-style. Pass the Violence Against Women Act. Although, the way he framed it actually frames women in terms that try to appeal to men that aren't going to support Obama policies anyway, instead of allowing those women to stand on their own right as independent women and supporters. They're also intimately tied to the proposal to raise the minimum wage, as more people, especially single mothers, are finding that their costs are more than their income, even with multiple part-time jobs all running concurrently.
Plank Five: Take care of the soldiers. Which is a twofold position - wind down the war that has already gone on too long, and then take care of the veterans that are coming back. Process their disability claims swiftly, get them the benefits they deserve, and help them with the stresses of readjusting to civilian life after a decade plus of deployments and combat.
The Interlude: The voting process needs reform. Because 200,000 people not voting in Florida is a bug. Because a 102 year-old woman shouldn't have to spend six hours to vote.
Plank Six: Let's actually put in some meaningful gun reform. Or, at the very least, put those proposals that have been drafted to a proper up-or-down vote. STOP BEING OBSTRUCTIONISTS, GOP. Most of their constituency is okay with sensible reforms and against the NRA's more extreme stances.
And that was the speech. The question is whether or not the GOP will decide to abandon the "must not let Obama win at any cost!" ideology. The Republican Response would show whether or not they were ready to grow up and act like serious people...
...the result? FAILURE. (And the Beltway should be ashamed of themselves for focusing on the water-drinking instead of the substantive commentary.) Sorry, Senator Rubio, your star has entered a decaying orbit.
The Republican Response appeared to be disjonited and not related to the speech that preceded it. We're using the Fox News Insider transcript.
The opening lines talk about immigration leading to "Hey, I have the potential to do well, and that's the most important thing, not like that socialist way of thinking that says people need more than opportunity to succeed!" The Obama is a Socialist meme died before the Birthers came into existence. Let it go.
Furthermore, the idea that government was the problem of the economic crisis and slow recovery is empirically discredited. The Big Government thing is not true, either - at least not in the financial area that has been deregulated to the point of allowing such crisis problems to happen. Blaming the government and the Affordable Care Act for private employers not hiring is disingenuous - it's the employers that decide not to hire because they're more interested in profit for certain individuals, not the government.
The false motives attack is, erm, disproven by your own colleagues, Senator Rubio. Mr. Ryan's plan for entitlements was not just "more flexibilty for states", it was "a block of money that everyone has to fight over". Most of the candidates fielded in the last election catered quite a bit to the rich - Mr. Romney, Mr. Brown, Mr. Ryan... there's moer of a pattern there than you can admit, Mr. Rubio. (Also, how's the list price of your house coming?) The Republican Party needs to pay attention to the effects of their policies on everyone, not just on their donors. (Have an example: Republicans love big government when it's about shaming poor people. And even the libertarians are all for big government when it suits their needs.)
Also, while it's nice to say that the economy needs to grow, we like concrete plans explaining how, rather than just saying that mythical growth will solve all our problems. "Solyndra" jab is low. "Government creates more debt than ever" is false, as is "the real cause of our debt is Obama's spending and nothing else."
And that final swing, saying that many of our problems are moral and have to be fixed that way? I'd like to know what you mean specifically about that, Senator Rubio, since it seems pretty obvious to me that you're calling out soe of your fellow Americans for being moral degerates. I'd like to know who they are that you mean, so that they know you don't represent them or care about them.
It just didn't address the things in the President's speech, and it rehashed several old lines of attack. So I guess the GOP still doesn't really want to be ready to be responsible grownups. (Based on behavior since, that theory is pretty well confirmed.)
The beginning is normally boilerplate, or sometimes a stretch, to show off the things that are improved in the union this past year. Considering we're still crawling ourselves out of a recession, there was a lot of low-hanging fruit to pick. Recognizing that there was still a long way to go helped. Making mention that the remining war and its cost can come to an end soon is also a good thing. Pointing out that the American people expect their government to govern could have been a much sharper edge used, if one were trying to go for accuracy, but just saying so probably caused gasps in the mainstream media.
Then come the commonsense reforms - cut defense, reform the tax code to be fairer, and STOP BEING OBSTRUCTIONISTS, GOP. Increase jobs by funding projects to innovate in many areas.
Plank two: climate change. Start shooting for multiple targets - energy independence, reduced climate emissions, and more/better renewables and clean energy. Fix the infrastructure that supports all of these innovations. (It creates jobs!) Let people refinance their mortgages so as to free up some money.
Plank three: Universal preschool and high schools that can get students out with the skills needed to get jobs. Early learning research says that having quality preschool is very helpful for getting kids ready for schooling. And if our high schools could graduate students that could get good jobs, that's excellent, instead of requiring a collegiate degree to make minimum wage in an unrelated field.
Plank Four: Raise the standard of living. Reform immigration, DREAM-style. Pass the Violence Against Women Act. Although, the way he framed it actually frames women in terms that try to appeal to men that aren't going to support Obama policies anyway, instead of allowing those women to stand on their own right as independent women and supporters. They're also intimately tied to the proposal to raise the minimum wage, as more people, especially single mothers, are finding that their costs are more than their income, even with multiple part-time jobs all running concurrently.
Plank Five: Take care of the soldiers. Which is a twofold position - wind down the war that has already gone on too long, and then take care of the veterans that are coming back. Process their disability claims swiftly, get them the benefits they deserve, and help them with the stresses of readjusting to civilian life after a decade plus of deployments and combat.
The Interlude: The voting process needs reform. Because 200,000 people not voting in Florida is a bug. Because a 102 year-old woman shouldn't have to spend six hours to vote.
Plank Six: Let's actually put in some meaningful gun reform. Or, at the very least, put those proposals that have been drafted to a proper up-or-down vote. STOP BEING OBSTRUCTIONISTS, GOP. Most of their constituency is okay with sensible reforms and against the NRA's more extreme stances.
And that was the speech. The question is whether or not the GOP will decide to abandon the "must not let Obama win at any cost!" ideology. The Republican Response would show whether or not they were ready to grow up and act like serious people...
...the result? FAILURE. (And the Beltway should be ashamed of themselves for focusing on the water-drinking instead of the substantive commentary.) Sorry, Senator Rubio, your star has entered a decaying orbit.
The Republican Response appeared to be disjonited and not related to the speech that preceded it. We're using the Fox News Insider transcript.
The opening lines talk about immigration leading to "Hey, I have the potential to do well, and that's the most important thing, not like that socialist way of thinking that says people need more than opportunity to succeed!" The Obama is a Socialist meme died before the Birthers came into existence. Let it go.
Furthermore, the idea that government was the problem of the economic crisis and slow recovery is empirically discredited. The Big Government thing is not true, either - at least not in the financial area that has been deregulated to the point of allowing such crisis problems to happen. Blaming the government and the Affordable Care Act for private employers not hiring is disingenuous - it's the employers that decide not to hire because they're more interested in profit for certain individuals, not the government.
The false motives attack is, erm, disproven by your own colleagues, Senator Rubio. Mr. Ryan's plan for entitlements was not just "more flexibilty for states", it was "a block of money that everyone has to fight over". Most of the candidates fielded in the last election catered quite a bit to the rich - Mr. Romney, Mr. Brown, Mr. Ryan... there's moer of a pattern there than you can admit, Mr. Rubio. (Also, how's the list price of your house coming?) The Republican Party needs to pay attention to the effects of their policies on everyone, not just on their donors. (Have an example: Republicans love big government when it's about shaming poor people. And even the libertarians are all for big government when it suits their needs.)
Also, while it's nice to say that the economy needs to grow, we like concrete plans explaining how, rather than just saying that mythical growth will solve all our problems. "Solyndra" jab is low. "Government creates more debt than ever" is false, as is "the real cause of our debt is Obama's spending and nothing else."
And that final swing, saying that many of our problems are moral and have to be fixed that way? I'd like to know what you mean specifically about that, Senator Rubio, since it seems pretty obvious to me that you're calling out soe of your fellow Americans for being moral degerates. I'd like to know who they are that you mean, so that they know you don't represent them or care about them.
It just didn't address the things in the President's speech, and it rehashed several old lines of attack. So I guess the GOP still doesn't really want to be ready to be responsible grownups. (Based on behavior since, that theory is pretty well confirmed.)